Actually, this pic is a perfect illustration for today's post, since a crime has definitely been committed in this blog entry. The following exercise was prepared for Livia Blackburne's Alternate Version Blogfest. We were challenged to take a scene from our story and re-write it in another style.
Writing in other genres, or different styles, is hard for me! The grooves in my author's fingerprints run deep. But, in the spirit of trying something new and stretching the old writing muscles, here it goes.
This excerpt is taken from a short story called When Opposites Attract. I was already way outside my comfort zone when I wrote the story, which was penned for a contest that only accepted Speculative Fiction. Below is the original snippet, and then a new version written with the flare of drama/chick lit romance. (Although, even I don't think: (A)That's actually a real genre; and (B)that I hit my mark. :P)
Original Version
Marla caught up to him and matched his long stride. “No shit, Robb. But that’s not the point. The Federation did take over and you no longer have clearance to be here. Disobeying the Federation is an act of treason. If you’re caught…”
He spun on her, grabbing her arm in a vice-like grip. “Now why would I get caught?”
His tone was dangerous, threatening. How far before a stretched rubber band breaks? He’d already come close to the edge of reason with Marla recently, when he’d walked in on her and Steve. That day, he’d understood how people can snap, grab a weapon and take out a few well-deserving people. In the dark days that'd followed, he’d fantasized about tying Marla up, torturing her until she hurt as much as he did. He’d been pathetic, twisted by tormented emotions, but he’d gotten a grip on himself. He'd resolved to be content on hurting her in small ways every chance he got, with spiteful words and defamatory rumors, little pressure valve acts to release his emotional tension and avoid a massive explosion. But the pain was still fresh. God help her if she pushed him now.
Marla was the one to break his gaze. She looked away, hugging her files to her chest. He turned and marched on, though he was aware of her soft footfalls behind him.
Alternate Version
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
And I hope you check out the other participants' blogs today. Find the Mr. Linky list by clicking HERE
30 comments:
Wow, I like the new snippet the best. It pops with witty dialog.
:) Great job.
Great job, Nicole! I took part too, it is great fun rewriting stuff!
I liked how the point of view changed when you rewrote it - that happened in one of my rewrites too! I wonder are some styles just better suited to a male or a female protagonist? The feminist in me is screaming 'No!' but the writer thinks she may be wrong. . . :)
I thought you did a great job with the style change. I know it's hard to do that sometimes, but I really enjoyed the dialogue!
Great job tackling the style change and great job at it too. I like both, but I do like your first style of writing more. It reminds me of the type of writing I like when I'm reading books.
I liked the first version best. But, I am not a romance reader. Well done, however. I think many women would prefer the second...
I like both versions, but the first one is the one that caught my attention best. Great!!
I think this was well done. I like the change in perspective. You just may have inspired me to give it a go.
Well done, Nicole! I like both versions but I think my favourite is the first one.
What a great idea.
NickiD! it's me Harley from WDC! I found you through Dawn's blog! I'm so glad to see you here!
You did a great job with this! I can't decide which version I like best!
I am off to post mine up in a few minutes!
I almost didn't participate in this blogfest because I have a terrible time shaking things up into a new style, but I'm glad I did! It's always nice to stretch the brain a bit!
I love that you wrote these from the male PoV! That's my favorite! I think the alternate version came out really great.
200 Followers ;)
Interesting.
The head-hopping kind of threw me. Actually, now that I reread it, I see it's in Robb's POV, but that wasn't apparent at first. I think you could tighten the POV by saying not what she did but what he experienced in that first line. Something like, "The click of stilettos pursued him."
I think the first one gets bogged down in telling and backstory, but the second flows a little better.
I don't really understand what happens in it. In both cases he seems to ask her a question that goes unanswered.
Anyways I like the second better, I actually get a better sense of who he is. The first kinda turned me off to him.
Nice job!
I really loved the first one, but you did a great job with the mood and style change. Great Job.
Great job shifting gears and genres. I really liked the AU version you wrote. And I can't believe I forgot all about this. :) Oh, well. I'll have an entry up for tomorrow's First Pages blogfest.
Such a good time to be a reader around here. :)
Nice job, really nice. The second one was sooo quarky...do I really write like that? It's sort of my genre.
That's a fun scene to wake up to. Haha. Happy April Fools Day! Good job with your scenes too. The two versions are very different. Personally, I like the first the best. It feels more natural, refined, and having read your blog I can hear your voice in that one. The second definitely sounds like someone else, but that's the point, right? Great job. Good luck!
Love the "crime scene" photo -- hehehe. And I really enjoyed the two versions of the story. I write a little bit like your alternate version, and it was funny to see an unrelated piece transformed into that genre. Nicely done! :)
Nice job on both! Hmm ... I should try that.
I just wanted to pipe up that at least according to a lot of agents, "chick lit" *is* kind of its own genre. ;-)
Great job. It definitely ended out very different. I like the second version because it seemed to flow better to me. It was a little less angsty without the "cheating" element, or that's how I interpreted the first entry.
You did very well, either way.
The alt version doesn't read as chick lit to me, but I think that's because it's a guy's POV more than anything else. And I love his voice - it's clear and distinctive. You've done a great job retelling the same info completely differently!
Loving the new snippet! It rocks!!!
Oh my gosh you guys are so funny about your April Fools Gags! I did nothing, then again I'm not the most creative when it comes to those things!
Why am I here reading yours when I should be working on my own. *Slaps side of head* BAD DL!
They both were good though! :)
Great job. I totally missed this blogfest, but my brain has shut down for the holiday weekend, so I can't make it up.
That was fun! Totally different feel for both entries - nicely done :)
I like the first one best - more tension, more at stake. Great job!
I'm honoured! Thanks for the link and your lovely comments.
And for your scenes, I adore how the very first moment is so altered: from "No shit, Robb," to "Please Robb!" Perfect. And very tricky, shifting from one character to the other's perspective. Good answer to the challenge. Thanks for sharing it!
Well done! I liked the way you changed the perception of Marla from a meek/mousy type into a powerful female figure with a wardrobe change and dialogue. Just great :)
Nice. Robb is kinda scary in the first one, and it's cool to see the transformation into playboy Robb
Haha, I think I like Playboy Robb a little more as well. Maybe there's a "happy medium"? (I'm so kidding.)
My post was a little late on 4/1, but I'd love to get your thoughts! http://bit.ly/a5PWNC
Post a Comment