Thursday, March 18, 2010

My Big Fat Patchwork Novel


We've heard a quilt is a metaphor for life so many times that it's become cliché. And I try to avoid using clichés...so I'll put on it my own twist and use it anyways to explain why I'm struggling so much with my WIP.

This quilt was the first I'd ever attempted, my debut textile project. As you can see, I didn't start out sewing a small, crib-size quilt with a simple four-block pattern. Instead, I chose a complicated nine-patch block, of which five patches were constructed from tiny triangles. I never considered a crib quilt -- I skipped right to queen size. And, I added to the original pattern, creating two additional borders (the skinny yellow border and the border that's a single row of stars were my ideas). As I struggled with my WIP outline this week, I realized that my creative methods are the same, regardless of the medium I'm working with. It's surely a mild form of arrogance, or perhaps an inability to know my own boundaries, but I've never been able to accept myself as a novice.


Short stories are easier for me to write. I'm comfortable dealing with one significant moment in time. Transitioning to the format of a novel is brand new territory for me. But like my big fat first quilt project, I've thrown myself into the deep end of the creative pool.

Rather than construct a linear plot that fits into a basic three act formula, I'm working with two distinct storylines. Two strangers, dealing with the conflicts in their lives, are fated to cross paths after a computer-generated phone call puts them on a collision course. Their lives don't intersect until midway through the book. Until then, chapters go back and forth, sometimes narrated by one character in one part of the country, and other times narrated by the other in a different city, so that the reader understands and sympathizes with both by the time they arrive at their crossroad.

I've struggled with tying their two separate experiences together. I'm worried the book will come across fractual, with odd patchwork pieces that don't fit together. My answer to this quandary is theme. Both characters, as different as their circumstances and as polar opposite as they are on the morality scale, are connected by the theme(s) I'm exploring throughout the book.

A novice novelist? Me? (*chuckles condescendingly, as if to herself*) You must have me confused with someone who doesn't know what she's doing.


Do you ever feel like your creative ideas exceed your skills? Do you think big and then scale down? Or does your confidence grow as you write, so that your end result is more successful than you imagined it'd be?

32 comments:

Summer Frey said...

Oh, yes! It seems like every idea I get is so colossal that when the infatuation wears off, I'm left with an Everest to write.

Probably why I have so many unfinished works. However, as I get older and more experienced, I do look back on projects and think, "I could probably handle this now."

All creative types have some sort of ego, right? We're just healthily exercising ours.

PS: That quilt is lovely!

Unspoken said...

My ideas nearly always exceed my abilities :)! The quilt (from one who sews) is amazing!

Aubrie said...

I'm definitely like you in that I started writing an entire novel before I ever wrote a short story. I finished the novel, but now I write shorts as well and I find that those have helped my bigger picture writing! Great post and lovely quilt.

Anne Gallagher said...

When you write short stories you said, "I deal with one significant moment in time."

Perhaps that is what you should do with this, instead of trying to figure out the problem, write the work in significant moments in time and then let the characters figure out how to solve the problem. Yeah, I know, I talk to myself a lot but once I let the characters do the talking, I just sit back, relax and type like crazy.

Just a thought.

Your quilt is BEAUTIFUL!!! And there is nothing wrong with taking on more than you can chew (sew), I'm building a fence and have no idea how to do it.

Stina said...

Your quilt is gorgeous! I tried quilting a baby quilt once. Let's just say I'm a better writer and photographer than I am a quilter. And mine wasn't even complex.

I'm not sure if I think my creative ideas exceed my skill. I just do it. But my confidence does grow as I write, and I try to challenge myself each time I sit down at the keyboard.

Jemi Fraser said...

Sometimes my ideas terrify me because I don't know quite how I'm going to pull it off. But it's fun trying :)

Tahereh said...

this is a really great post -- so insightful. i don't really formulate my ideas until i'm halfway into the story -- i've never been able to outline anything. so i'm not sure. sometimes i find i have to go back and revise the beginning to accommodate unexpected changes in the end, but in general it's easy to get overwhelmed.

something to think about.

thanks for sharing!!

Sarah Ahiers said...

first off, the quilt is WONDERFUL!
also, i'm reading Manuscript Makeover which is about revision and editing techniques, and they have a section of the book dedicated to stories that are exactly like yours, with the converging timelines of 2 separate characters

Travener said...

I'm OK at coming up with an overarching idea -- "OK, I'll write a book about a Viking detective." But coming up with a plot is where it gets tricky. I usually think I'm a talentless wretch until a lot's down on paper.

Anthony Duce said...

I liked your writing today. You helped me think about all the stories I've started, and have left waiting as a bigger idea is starts. I have files full of short stories and the outline for longer stories I had to get down down and carried as far as I could while the ideas were in my head. I've only finished a few, but I've rarely thought I'm not qualified or able to finish any of them. Some new idea or my art and before that my business would just get in the way. The newest idea would have me off drawing or painting and I don't want to stop working on the next idea enough to buckle down and finish what I started. I know thats why I let painting and drawing come first. I can fulfill what I wanted to accomplish usually in one sitting.

Unknown said...

Summer~ You always make me feel less alone! Thanks for the encouragement!

She Writes~ Ooh, a fellow sewer! I realized (fortunately) early in this project that if my seam allowances weren't perfectly maintained from block to block, the star points weren't going to match up when I sewed the rows together. Learn-as-I-go seems to be another strong theme in my creative life!

Aubrie~ I agree, short story writing is an excellent companion activity to writing novels. Especially considering Piedmont Writer's advice!

Piedmont~ I agree, Anne. My sister is a novelist (who doesn't blog...yet) and she tells me to approach each chapter like a short story. That seems to go hand-in-hand with advice from writers about having an entry and exit plot point for each chapter.

Stina~ Thanks for the compliment! And I think I'm like you in that my confidence grows as I write. Maybe that's why getting past the beginning is so hard for me this time around!

Jemi~ That's what I keep reminding myself: have fun! I love writing, so I need to peel that layer of angst off my muse and enjoy the process again.

Tahereh~ I love writing by the seat of my pants, but I need the structure of at least a loose outline to get me started. After that, I go where the story takes me, regardless of what I "plotted" to say.

Falen~ Thanks for the title, Sarah! I'm going to look for that book this week. Thanks!!

Shelley Sly said...

Wonderful post! I can relate to what you mean by thinking big and then scaling down, which is how I created my first novel. I could have kept going with that book long after it ended, but I had to stop somewhere.

Now that I'm outlining my third novel, I'm finding that I'm doing things a bit differently. I actually have a bunch of little ideas that wouldn't be big enough for a novel, but when put together, would work quite nicely. Is that kind of like sewing a few crib blankets together to make a larger quilt? Like you said, I'm a little worried that the book will feel like it's oddly pieced together, but I'll deal with that once I actually start writing. :)

Unknown said...

Travener~ Plot is tricky for me, too. I'm such a character-driven writer that I can come up with a character's evolutionary arc, but then I struggle to figure out what scenes to write that will show that progression. In my short stories, I've always pulled it off in the end, but not after passing through the "I'm-a-talentless-wretch" phase you talked about. LOL

Anthony~ Ah, the curse of the creative mind! I can completely understand the allure of painting and drawing. Seeing the project's completion in a relatively short time, certainly compared to the year(s) it takes to write long fiction, would tempt me on a daily basis!

Katie said...

I definitely get this feeling. When I was finishing my last WIP, I was outlining and thinking "What have I gotten myself into?" That ending took a ridiculous amount of time, because I had to tie everything together; but in the end, I think it's my best work. Pushing ourselves and going beyond what we think we can do makes us better, I think.

Unknown said...

Shelley~ I think you touched on one of my problems: This is my first experience writing a novel. I keep telling myself to get this one written, however I need to write it, so that I gain the experience and the skills I need. I'll do things differently next time, for sure, but each project will feel a bit easier than the last. Right? ... Please say "right" :P

Unknown said...

KM~ I LOVE that you just said that! You're so right, if it were easy, it wouldn't be worth the time to accomplish. Thanks -- I needed to be reminded of that!!

Abby Annis said...

Like you, I tend to go for the most complicated route when it comes to creative endeavors. But that's what makes it interesting for me. I suppose it could partly be because of arrogance. ;)

I think your idea sounds really cool! Challenging, yes, but it would be so rewarding if you could make it work. Good luck!

Roxy said...

Hi, Nicole. That quilt is gorgeous! I'm so impressed with your creation. In terms of writing, I don't think of size, but most of my projects generally exceed my abilities. I learn as I go, and I try to get better.

Kimberly Franklin said...

That quilt is BEAUTIFUL! Beautiful!!!

I constantly doubt myself, but I just keep at it. Because I know that eventually the words will come and my story will look like and read like the one in my head. Plus, I'm too OCD to quit! LOL. It would drive me insane. : )

Happy Thursday!!

Shelley Sly said...

Nicole, right you are! Second and third novels are usually easier than the first, even if they are different and have their own challenges, you have a better idea of what to expect. :)

Elana Johnson said...

Okay, first, I cannot believe you sew. If I tried something like that, all the corners wouldn't match up. Believe me, I HAVE tried. And failed. I despise sewing.

Second, I do think my skills have a long way to go. I always think big and wonder why I've got so much to do. And my endings always suck. So I start over and by the time I've made it through a few passes, I finally think it might be ready for someone to read.

DL Hammons said...

YES...YES...YES....YES!!!!!

I would rather dream big and reach, then play it safe and languish.

Pat Tillett said...

Yes, I have too many ideas. They start out as novels, but end up as short stories. Then when it's done, I think I chose the wrong route.

Talli Roland said...

Great question, and I love the analogy of a novel as a quilt. I often worry about my novle being too fragmented, especially when I have several voices to tie in.

I'm always wondering if I'm aiming too high, but it doesn't lead me to scale down my ideas. Maybe it should!

Cherie Reich said...

Wow! That's an amazing quilt!

Personally, I find short stories easier to write, and I like to think of novels in a similar fashion. They are significant moments in time. Sometimes I work with outlines and other times I think of a chapter for several days/weeks and then write it. Then, I think up the next chapter.

The only thing I can think of with the novel you mentioned is that when you get to the part where their paths cross, that you should continue to write chapters from one character's point of view. Each chapter can switch to the other character, but it would be easier probably on you and the reader to not mix points of view in the same chapter. Of course, you might have already planned this, but I think that would help pull it together instead of having characters war it out for POV.

Lola Sharp said...

Oh yeah. I'm the queen of biting off more than I can chew...but I've learned that it's because I enjoy the challenge, the learning. I trust myself to figure it out, eventually. Anything worth doing is worth stretching for and doing well.

Plus, that is why rewrites exist, my friend!

I loved this post, your gorgeous quilt, and your honesty.

Love,
Lola

Unknown said...

Abby~ Thanks for the encouragement! And, I've been thinking all day about your excerpt posted at Fiction Groupie. That it's staying with me proves how much I enjoyed it. Can't wait to read more!

Roxy~ I'm a learn as I go gal too. I never shy away from a challenge, even though achieving my objectives is sometimes tough. Thanks for stopping in!

Kimberly~ Actually, a little bit of OCD is great for quiltmaking. When I started this one, my husband watched me silently for a couple minutes before asking, "So...you're going to cut all this whole fabric into itty-bitty pieces, and then sew them together again?" "Yep." LOL!

((hugs)) Shelley

Elana~ Yeah, I'm unsure how my story ends... Next time around, I hope I start with an ending and construct a story to lead up to it. That sounds easier!

DL~ Well said, my friend!

Pat~ I know a lot of people who've expanded their short stories into full length novels, but I've never given it a shot...yet :)

Talli~ Good! You sound like me, and that makes me feel saner, LOL. Thanks!!

Cherie~ I couldn't agree more! I have a natural aversion to multiple viewpoints within a chapter. I don't like it when I read it, so I won't write that way either. I like the idea of giving whole chapters over to each character. That way, the reader has the chance to really get under the character's skin and fully sympathize with him, even if they don't "like" him (in the case of an antagonist). Great advice I will definitely follow! Thanks!!

Lola~ You're so right, the challenge is well worth the journey to success. And anyhow, I often joke that I'm not a writer, I'm a re-writer. LOL!

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Michelle Gregory said...

Nicole,
lovely quilt. thanks for stopping by beautiful chaos and leaving a comment.

Anonymous said...

I have yet to brew an idea that I feel qualified to write. I've never felt good enough to write the things I've written. So when I go back and re-read what I've done, sometimes I wonder who actually wrote it. And other times it's painfully clear that I did it.

Your quilts are beautiful, by the way!

bull said...

If you are having trouble, you might want to start at the end of your novel, make your chapters and the put them in order

bull said...

then