Friday, March 19, 2010

Snowflakes in Spring

I've plotted out short stories before writing them, and I've written stories by-the-seat-of-my-pants. The end results were the same, in that I was pleased with the success of the final drafts. I can't say for certain which method took me longer, since I never paid attention to timing.

With my novel-in-progress, I've tried both pantsing and plotting. Draft #1 was nineteen chapters of NaNoWriMo word vomit -- pantsing to the tenth power. Realizing I needed some structure to move forward, I attempted to construct some sort of outline from what I'd already written, taking into account the major character change I made to the protagonist which dictated scrapping half of her chapters, anyway. I had major breakthrough #1 the other day when I sat down with index cards, sketched already-written and new scenes, and put them in tentative chronological order. Then, major breakthrough #2 happened last night.

I was blog-hopping when I found the articles, but when I navigated away from the blog I couldn't remember where I'd been. [If I find you again, awesome blogger with the link, I'll definitely give you a big shout-out chez moi !]

I'd first read about Randy Ingermanson's Snowflake Method after it came up in a regional meet-n-greet for NaNo participants. The funny thing about knowledge is the timing has to be right. At the time, all I had was a premise for a novel, and I was geared up to try the much-touted stream-of-consciousness writing embraced by NaNo. The Snowflake Method seemed complicated and tedious, and not for me.

Last night, I read through it again. Epiphany! Ingermanson's Snowflake Method is a ten step process in which you prepare your novel starting with a one sentence summary. Each step builds on that sentence, that summary, until by step ten you're ready to bang out your first draft.

Ingermanson's repeated disclaimer is that not all writers will be successful with the method. He says many "pantsers" will think the method too left-brained, that it dams up the creative flow. For a total right-brained writer like me, and where I am creatively right now, I think the method will provide exactly the kind of structure I crave. I've pantsed the plot for five months now, and I still don't know exactly what's going to happen by the end of the story.

I felt excited and inspired while reading through the article, and as of this morning, steps one and two are complete. I look forward to each step in the process, especially getting to writing the actual draft. Here's what Ingermanson says during his explanation of step ten:

"This stage is incredibly fun and exciting. I have heard many writers complain about how hard the first draft is. Invariably, they are seat-of-the-pants writers who have no clue what's coming next. Good grief! Life is too short to write like that! There is no reason to spend 500 hours writing a wandering first draft of your novel when you can write a solid one in 150. Counting the 100 hours it takes to do the design documents, you come out way ahead in time."

Amen!!


Have you tried the Snowflake Method before? Are you a plotter or a pantser? Or are you like me and describe yourself as somewhere in the middle?

19 comments:

Stina said...

Until this post, I'd never heard of the term. I come up with a one liner first (okay, that's a new thing for me), then build from there. I'll brainstorm ideas, work on a few key characterizations, that leads to more ideas, and outline. Hmmm. Sounds like pretty much the same thing. Hey, what do you know? I'm a snowflaker. :)

Julie Dao said...

I've heard of the Snowflake method but have yet to try it! I am such a plotter, but it's extremely self-limiting and stressful. I wish I could be a spur-of-the-moment writer and I have tried to free write occasionally, but I never get a good sense of purpose for the story until I make a detailed outline. Guess it's just the way I write, but I hope I can slowly move down the spectrum towards the middle!

Portia said...

I've never tried it, but I confess I've been intrigued. I've read about the Snowflake method before, so I'm eager to hear how it works for you!

Jen said...

It's been a while since I've made it over this way.

I have not heard of the Snowflake Method before. I'm interested to learn more. Off to check out the link you posted. Thanks!

Jen

Unknown said...

Stina~ You're an instinctual snowflaker! I'm learning so much about myself as a writer; it's fascinating to try on new things and see what fits. So far, I find my approach a little different from project to project.

Julie~ When I finally sit down to write, I agonize over each sentence. I haven't perfected the stream-of-conscious flow some writers talk about. But I don't plot so well either! It's amazing I get anything down on paper at all, LOL!!

Portia~ So far, so good (into Step Three already!); I'll definitely share my ups and downs :)

Jen~ Hey!! Great to hear from you! I'd love to hear your reactions if you read the article :)

Lisa Rusczyk said...

Interesting way to write. I tend to brainstorm and get most of what I want for the story crammed in my noggin', then whatever is still in there when I go to write will make its way into the MS. Sometimes I'll make notes, sometimes not.

Annika said...

Never heard of this, sounds very promising I do need to check it out, thanks for the tip!
I have never been able to (yet) complete a WIP... Usually I get this idea and just start writing. But then lose inspiration.
It seems, for me, that I work best when I have some structure and guidelines! Just to keep me on track and not feeling so 'stuck in one place'!
Lovely!

Anthony Duce said...

Thank you for the information.

Talli Roland said...

Haven't heard of the snowflake method. I usually try to plot out turning point 1, turning point 2, climax and resolution, then fill in the gaps when I'm writing.

PS - Drop my blog when you have a chance; I have an award there for you!

Summer Frey said...

I first saw this on Jon Arnston (?)'s blog and checked it out...I'm still iffy about it, though. Seems TOO structured for me. Outlines can be good, but this one...geez...

Good luck with it, though. Maybe it'll give you what you need to get through to the end.

Anne Gallagher said...

Well, I'll have to take a look at this, sounds intriguing. Have something at my blog for you when you get a minute.

sarahjayne smythe said...

I've never tried it but I'm up for new things right now. :) I'll have to give it a look see.

Dana Elmendorf said...

Nicole, it feels like blog hijack doesn't it? Odd seeing the same blog style as my blog but the wrong content. We'll thanks for stopping by my blog. Yours is just gorgeous!

B.J. Anderson said...

Thanks for the link! I'm a bit of both. I started out as a die-hard panster, but the more books I wrote, the more I realized I needed a little structure. My results have been better. :D Great post!

Anonymous said...

Snowflake Method doesn't work for me. What does is Michael Hauge and Chris Vogler's The Hero's Two Journeys.

But we all have different ways of turning on the lightbulb :)

Kimberly Franklin said...

I've heard the snowflake method works really well. For me, I'm a "I-dont-know-what-I-am-ser" LOL. I've tried pantsing it and plotting it and it all just causes me to pull my hair out. So, obviously I'm still trying to find my way. Maybe I should try this snowflake method everyone is talking about. : )

Shelley Sly said...

I had never heard of the Snowflake Method before. Interesting!

I am definitely a plotter, but my degrees of plotting vary from project to project. My first novel was outlined so thoroughly, there was hardly any room to stray from my plans. It wasn't until maybe the fifth rewrite that I finally broke out of that mold.

My second novel had an outline, but it was more open ended. As long as I met my objective in each scene, it didn't matter how I got there.

I admire "pantsers", because I imagine there's fun in the element of surprise, wondering what's going to happen in the story.

Jennie Englund said...

I have to admit being a virgin at snowflaking.

But the concept is interesting, and I'm excited to try!

And hey, I absolutely LOVED your comments on my blog!!!

Sarah Ahiers said...

I LOVE the snowflake method!

I use only about the first 6 steps, but they really help me with plotting and getting some character conflict worked out beforehand