Wednesday, February 10, 2010

How to Avoid Weak Story Endings

A story, like all “good things,” must come to an end. The ending, also known as Denouement, is as important to the story as the Beginning and the Middle . A good ending leaves the reader with a sense that the story has come to a logical, satisfying conclusion. For writers, it's important to remember what an ending shouldn’t do. By understanding what constitutes a weakly executed ending, we're more likely to avoid these pitfalls in our writing.


A story ending SHOULDN’T:


Leave Unanswered Questions – Regardless of the length of a story, be it flash fiction or a novel, the ending should tie up all the loose plot strings. All issues, minor or major, introduced in a story must serve a purpose and move the plot forward. By the end of the story, the reader should have answers to all questions posed in the narration and have learned how the character(s) cleared all their obstacles.

Make the Reader Decide What Happened – You want your reader to feel satisfied by the outcome of the story. This doesn’t mean you need to spoon-feed exactly what happens in a play-by-play commentary. Readers enjoy having enough information to imagine what happens next, beyond The End. What frustrates most readers is realizing the story has led them to a plot intersection, and the author has placed on their shoulders the burden of deciding how the story ends.

Be Too Abrupt – Have you ever read a story that was chugging along at an enjoyable pace, and suddenly it was over? This usually happens when the climactic scene is pushed up against the ending, and the writer skipped right over the falling action. Authors need to be mindful of the pacing of events and manipulate the emotional impact each moment has on the reader. The reader should be left with the impression the ending was the natural conclusion to the story, the terrain that leveled out at the bottom of the hill, rather than feel like the plot had been pushed off a cliff.

Be Too Long – Another pacing problem occurs when the time between the climactic scene and the story’s end is too long. The story seems to fizzle out. All the excitement of earlier scenes is forgotten. If your ending is too long-winded, you risk boring your reader.

Be Illogical – Your ending must make sense on two fronts, Plot and Character(s):

*Bullet* Plot: Resolution of the central problem has to be achieved by means of a logical chain of events. Suspension of belief is sacrificed when the ending promotes a breakdown of cause and effect. The reader simply won’t buy it.

*Bullet* Characters: If during the story’s ending, a character behaves in a way that is in direct contrast with his or her established personality, with no logical explanation for the shift in behavior, the reader is going to raise an eyebrow. The character, and the ending, will feel false and contrived.

Be Too Predictable – Readers love a story with a twist. It doesn’t have to be something earth-shattering. However, a creative ending that sheds new light on what the reader believed to be true will ‘up’ the entertainment factor of the whole story. On the other hand, if the reader has suspected a predictable ending since the rising action, s/he will feel let down, and the entire story will seem uninspired and weak.

Have a “Night in Shining Armor” Save the Day – Readers want to feel emotionally invested in the main character’s future. They embrace the hero or heroine, who is flawed with conflicts s/he must rise above in the course of the story. When readers have been rooting for the heroine, cheering her on through her struggles, they aren’t going to appreciate someone else swooping in at the end of the story and saving the day.


The ending you write is important to the overall success of your story. It will show how far your characters have come since the beginning and wrap up their story. A clever ending leaves your readers inspired, satisfied, and intrigued. And even the strongest writing will fall short on the reader’s entertainment yardstick if the ending is weak.

The following article is a must-read! Willie Meikle explains ten overdone, clichéd endings that he feels, (and I agree!), should be avoided at all costs:

10 Story Endings To Avoid

I just finished reading The Giver, by Lois Lowry. (Look for my review in tomorrow's post.) The ending is cryptic and could be interpreted in several different ways. Do you like endings that ask you to interpret their meanings? Or do you prefer an ending that gives you the sense that you know what has, or will, happen? Is a "good ending" a "happy ending," in your view?

19 comments:

Abby Annis said...

I often feel frustrated with open endings. I like to feel like all the time I spent reading is rewarded by having at least the major plot lines tied up at the end, in a believable manner--which doesn't always mean it's a truly happy ending. Great post!

Anne Gallagher said...

Great post Nicole, I agree with evrything you said. If the ending sucks I'll never read that author again. I also hate short choppy endings. I don't mean they have to be 50 pages long, but the last chapter has to be continuous, not, he did, she did, they kiss, the end.

Tara said...

What a great post! I rewrote my ending three times. Not edited--rewrote. Almost nothing of the original ending is left; I just reread that last night. Boy was it horrible.

And, while it still needs a little tweaking, I am happy to say I've avoided all 10 Story Endings to Avoid :-)

Unknown said...

Abby Annis~ What a great way to say it: the ending should be a reward, like the icing on the cake, for the time invested in reading the book. I never thought of it this way before!

Piedmont~ I won't read a second offering from a writer that didn't deliver in the first book I read. The writing world is uber-competitive and there are so many books, so little time. Something we all need to think about as we're perfecting our manuscripts!

Tara~ I don't call myself a writer, I say I'm a re-writer! I think we know when a scene we wrote, especially the ending, isn't right. Thank goodness the writing journey is as rewarding as the destination!

Sarah Ahiers said...

oooh good post.
I loooove the Giver, but i'm not a huge fan of its ending because i don't like to interpret endings

Kelly Lyman said...

I like endings that give me a sense of what happened or will happen. It's not my story, so I don't want to guess, or think about it. I'm also a sucker for happy endings. I like the "they lived happily ever after" stuff.

Stina said...

This is great advice. The ending is often what the reader remembers long after they finish the book. If they don't like the ending, they might not buy your next book.

Anthony Duce said...

Thanks for the treat information. Makes me want to bring at least a few lingering stories to a good end.

Jemi Fraser said...

I love the Giver & it is very amibiguous. Jean Oram, Yvonne Osborne & I had some bloggy conversations about it a few weeks (months??) ago. Great book.

B.J. Anderson said...

Love this post. I've rewritten my ending so many times I don't know if I'm coming or going. Grrr.

Kimberly Franklin said...

I'm not a big fan of the open-ended ending, though in the right book they can be fantastic, too. I loved this post, by the way!

I'm a happy ending kind of girl.

lisa and laura said...

I haven't read The Giver in a long time, but I remember absolutely loving it. I get a little annoyed when an ending is wrapped up in a pretty little bow. I just don't think life is like that.

Anissa said...

Great post! And so timely for me. Thank you.

I like an ending to be satisfying but not too neat. I'm not a big fan of having to interpret what comes next. It feels like a cop-out.

I'm off to check out your link.

Laurel Garver said...

I like endings that point in the direction of change, that lay out a trajectory. Too neat and tidy grates a bit--I agree with what you said about giving readers some freedom to imagine the details themselves. If they're invested in the world you create, they love you for letting them live in that world and co-create. (Or at least as a reader I feel that way.)

Unknown said...

I love reading everyone's reactions to this post! So far, the majority of us prefer reading an ending that nudges our understanding of 'what's next' in a direction without gift wrapping the conclusion in a neat little package. This is the kind of feedback all writers will benefit from hearing!

Michele said...

grazie per i tuoi consigli
molto reali e importanti per un racconto
dovro' passare da te piu' spesso ma sono un pigro
ciao
Michele pianetatempolibero

Kelsey (Dominique) Ridge said...

I definitely concur with you about the Deux Ex Machine/Knight in Shining Armor deal. If someone else does all the hard stuff and saves the day, it's sort of boring. We care about MC doing things and MC's peril. If MC is just sitting on the sidelines, why would we care about them/the actions going on around them.

Christine Danek said...

I have not read the The Giver but I prefer endings that give you a sense of what has, or will, happen. I prefer happy endings although I thought the ending of Romeo and Juliet was brillant. I guess in a sense it was a happy ending:)

Erin Kuhns said...

This was a great post. I also checked out the link you posted. Both your words and Meikle's article offer excellent points. I'm so wary of "bad" endings that I really hope I don't ever follow one of the examples of a bad ending. Ever.

The end.